(BH91-94 points) A highly spiced nose of very ripe plum, cassis and warm earth scents is followed by relatively fine, supple and lush medium-bodied flavors that terminate in a robust, intense and overtly muscular finish that delivers excellent persistence. I very much like the depth and while not quite as structured as the Clos de Vougeot this will require an extended snooze in a cool cellar to realize its full, and considerable, potential.

(WA89-91 points) The 2012 Echezeaux Grand Cru has a lucid garnet/ruby color. Picked on September 25 with 15% whole cluster fruit, it has a sensual nose with strawberry jam and boysenberry fruit. Perhaps it is not as sophisticated as other growers’ Echezeaux, but it is very generous. The palate is medium-bodied with a fleshy, structured opening. With firm grip on its masculine finish, it is just missing a little complexity and breeding to merit a higher score. - Neal Martin