The 2005 Duhart-Milon-Rothschild is a Bordeaux Blend hailing from the renowned region of Pauillac in Bordeaux, France. Produced by the esteemed Duhart-Milon-Rothschild, this red wine exemplifies the rich heritage and meticulous care associated with Rothschild family wines.

Wine Spectator describes this vintage as "dark in color, almost black," with "beautiful aromas of spices, blackberry, and milk chocolate." The wine is full-bodied with a silky texture, yet retains a tannic backbone that promises longevity. Awarded a score of 93, it is deemed "gorgeous" and recommended for consumption after 2015.

Neal Martin's Wine Journal gives it a solid 91, highlighting its "classic bouquet" with notes of "blackcurrant, wild strawberry, tobacco, and clove." The wine is noted for its harmonious palate, fine tannins, and well-judged acidity, accented by hints of rosemary and clove on the finish. Martin emphasizes the wine's need for time to fully open up, indicating its potential for future development.

Robert Parker's Wine Advocate also awards the wine a 93, describing it as a "dense purple-colored wine" benefitting from significant investments by the Rothschild family. The wine is noted for its "broad, expansive, supple and silky tannin" and flavors of "Asian plum sauce, blackcurrants, and sweet cherries." Parker calls it "seductive" and predicts it will continue to drink well for at least two more decades.

Jeff Leve from TheWineCellarInsider.com offers a score of 92, describing the wine as "elegant, refined, soft, and medium-bodied" with a core of "fresh, sweet, bright, tobacco and earth-infused red fruits, flowers, and spice." He recommends allowing the wine another 2-4 years to mature, with a drinking window extending over the subsequent 15 years.

Overall, the 2005 Duhart-Milon-Rothschild is praised for its complexity, aging potential, and the careful craftsmanship that has revitalized the Duhart-Milon estate.