The 2010 Mouton-Rothschild, a Bordeaux Blend from the renowned region of Pauillac, Bordeaux, France, stands as a testament to the excellence of its producer, Mouton-Rothschild. Boasting an impressive 14.0% alcohol and sealed with a cork closure, this red wine has garnered extraordinary reviews from leading wine critics, underscoring its exceptional quality and longevity.
Jeff Leve of TheWineCellarInsider.com awarded the 2010 Mouton-Rothschild a perfect score of 100, praising its "incredible levels of intensity, density, richness, vibrancy and lift." Leve describes a "wall of fruit" that is "perfectly ripe," complemented by notes of "crushed rocks, flowers, spice box, lead pencil, currants, cassis, blackberries, and Cuban cigars." He emphasizes that this wine is "not for today" but for future generations, recommending it be enjoyed from 2030 to 2080.
John Sweeney from JJ Buckley also lauds this vintage, giving it a score between 96-98. He notes its "opulent nose of dark chocolate, coffee, cassis, and oak," and describes it as "plush with precision on the finish" and possessing "well-integrated tannins." Sweeney predicts it will last for over 40 years.
Neal Martin's Wine Journal gave it a near-perfect score of 99, highlighting its "tangible strictness and linearity" on the nose, which unfolds to reveal "blackberry, mulberry, truffle, and violets." The palate is described as "medium-bodied but the tannins are silky and fine," with a "bewitching texture" and "outstanding mineralite."
Wine Spectator, with a score of 99, calls it a "battleship of a wine," brimming with "cassis, blackberry, and fig fruit" and a "long finish loaded with grip." James Suckling also awarded it a perfect 100, noting its "incredible depth of fruit" and "ripe tannins that let go and seduce you."
Jancis Robinson scored it 95, mentioning its "sweet start" and "very savoury and meaty" characteristics. Robert Parker's Wine Advocate, with a score of 98, describes it as "deep garnet in color" and "solidly constructed of super firm, ripe, grainy tannins."
Decanter, another major publication, also awarded it a perfect 100, describing it as "accomplished and confident" with "plush, plumped fruits." Wine Enthusiast, with a score of 98, praises its "dense, smooth, and opulent" nature, while Jeb Dunnuck, scoring it 99, calls it "just about pure perfection."
In summary, the 2010 Mouton-Rothschild is a critically acclaimed wine, praised for its complexity, richness, and long-term aging potential. It stands as a pinnacle of what Pauillac and Mouton-Rothschild can achieve.