M. Chapoutier’s Ermitage “L’Ermite” 2015 is a flagship Northern Rhône Syrah from the L’Ermite lieu-dit high on the Hermitage hill, near the chapel, a site associated with very poor, stony granite soils. At about 14% alcohol, it’s a dry, full-bodied red built around concentration, mineral tension, and long-term aging. Chapoutier’s broader approach—widely linked to organic and biodynamic farming—shows through here in a wine that reviewers consistently frame as powerful but not blunt.
Critical reception is emphatically strong, led by two perfect scores. Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate awarded 100 points, with Joe Czerwinski calling it “complex, balanced and long, a true tour de force,” praising its “incredible purity of cassis fruit” alongside “massive concentration.” Jeb Dunnuck also gave 100 points, highlighting a “searing granite/ozone-laced bouquet of crème de cassis, liquid rocks, graphite, and lead pencil,” and predicting “40-50 years of prime drinking,” while advising it “needs to be forgotten for 8-10 years.”
Wine Spectator’s James Molesworth (98 points) emphasizes its depth of fruit—“boysenberry, fig and blackberry compote”—matched with “melted black licorice” and a “long, refined echo of minerality,” concluding: “A stunning wine that will require significant cellaring,” and suggesting a long window (“Best from 2020 through 2045”).
At slightly lower but still excellent levels, Vinous rated it 96, with Josh Raynolds noting “dark fruit preserves, incense, black pepper, violet,” and a palate that’s “wonderfully concentrated yet energetic,” finishing “strikingly long” with “steadily building tannins.” James Suckling also scored 96, describing it as “very fragrant and aromatically complex already,” with “layers of grainy, fresh tannins,” and noting it is “from organically grown grapes,” with a recommendation to “Drink in 2022.”
Taken together, the 2015 L’Ermite reads as a serious, cellar-first Hermitage: ripe and generous in fruit, distinctly granite-marked, and structured for decades rather than immediate gratification.