The 2016 Domaine Mugneret-Gibourg Nuits St Georges 1er Cru Les Chaignots Pinot Noir is a standout wine from Burgundy, France, showcasing the region's renowned winemaking prowess. This vintage is noted for its reduced production, with 35% less yield than usual, yet it has been met with critical acclaim.

Decanter awarded this wine a score of 94, describing it as "bursting with aromas of creamy black fruits, incense, spice, and grilled squab," and praising its "full-bodied, supple and expansive" character. The review highlights the wine's "long and penetrating finish," suggesting it as one of Burgundy's "best-kept secrets."

Similarly, Robert Parker's Wine Advocate also gave it a 94, emphasizing the "lovely bouquet of smoky cassis, wild berries, Asian spices, smoked meats, and violets." The palate is described as "medium to full-bodied, ample and layered," with a "lavish core of vibrant fruit" and a "long and expansive finish."

Burghound scored it slightly lower at 93, noting the "earthier and more evidently Nuits-like nose" with aromas of "red raspberry, dark cherry, and whiffs of the sauvage." The review mentions the wine's "mineral-driven and sleekly muscular flavors" and advises a few years of bottle aging for optimal enjoyment.

Vinous rated the wine at 91, noting an "impressive bouquet with well-defined black cherry, raspberry, spicebox, and rose petal aromas." While the review appreciated the "silky smooth texture," it felt the wine didn't quite deliver the full personality of the best wines from the appellation.

Jasper Morris also gave it a 94, highlighting the "imperial purple robe" and "sumptuous" bouquet, praising its "excellent acidity mixed in with the red fruit."

Overall, the 2016 Domaine Mugneret-Gibourg Les Chaignots is a well-regarded Pinot Noir with a rich bouquet and vibrant palate, promising excellent aging potential.