The 2018 Il Marroneto Brunello di Montalcino is a distinguished red wine from Tuscany, Italy, produced by Il Marroneto. This vintage is composed of Sangiovese Grosso grapes and is sealed with a cork closure. The wine has garnered significant acclaim from various professional reviewers, with scores predominantly in the mid-90s, indicating high quality and exceptional craftsmanship.
Jeb Dunnuck's Audrey Frick awarded the wine a score of 94. She described it as "highly expressive with medicinal herbs, sour black cherry, leather, clove, and burnt orange." Frick noted its medium to full-bodied nature, with "tangy acidity and ripe yet angular tannins" that contribute to a complex profile. She emphasized that the wine has potential for aging, projecting enjoyment over the next 20 years (jebdunnuck.com, 3/6/2023).
Decanter offered a slightly higher score of 95, praising the wine's elegance and accessibility. The review highlighted the "sweetness to the red berry core" and accented flavors of cinnamon stick, sarsaparilla, and violet. The tannins were described as "fine-grained and enveloping," with appetizing acidity that "begs another sip" (Decanter, 11/10/2022).
James Suckling gave the wine a score of 93, noting its "fresh, red fruit character with cherries and red plum" along with hints of gunpowder, coffee beans, spices, and dried orange peel. He found the wine to be medium- to full-bodied with "firm tannins and a supple, velvety core of fruit" (jamessuckling.com, 12/11/2022).
Vinous also scored the 2018 Brunello di Montalcino at 95, with Eric Guido describing it as having a "radiance" and "opulence of fruit" balanced by "juicy acidity." He noted that the wine "tapers off with rounded tannins" and has the structure to mature beautifully (Vinous, 12/1/2022).
Robert Parker's Wine Advocate, through Monica Larner, provided another 95-point review, emphasizing the wine's "spicy bouquet with hints of cumin and white pepper" and its balanced nature. Larner noted that the wine still possesses "life and vibrant energy" despite 39 months of aging in oak casks (Robert Parker's Wine Advocate, 3/10/2023).
Kerin O'Keefe rated the wine at 97, highlighting its "extreme elegance and vibrancy" and a palate featuring "juicy red cherries, white pepper, and dark spices." She found it to be "absolutely fantastic," recommending it be enjoyed between 2026 and 2043 (kerinokeefe.com, 11/1/2022).
Wine Enthusiast's Danielle Callegari also gave the wine a score of 97, describing it as "poised and elegant, yet also exciting." She noted the nose's "dreamy island getaway" qualities and a palate with "candied cherries and strawberries" (Wine Enthusiast, 12/1/2023).
Lastly, The Wine Independent's Susan Hulme rated it at 96, praising its "lifted, bright, floral aromas" and "vivid acidity on the finish." She noted the wine's "fine backbone" and "beautiful range of aromas and flavors" (The Wine Independent, 2/23/2023).
Overall, the 2018 Il Marroneto Brunello di Montalcino is a highly acclaimed wine known for its elegance, complexity, and potential for aging.