The 2019 Argiano Brunello di Montalcino is a Sangiovese Grosso varietal from the renowned region of Tuscany, Italy. Produced by Argiano, this red wine has garnered high praise from various professional reviewers for its balanced and exquisite profile.
Decanter rated the wine 94 points, noting its evocative sense of place with "salt-tinged sweet herbs, rose, and bergamot." The review highlights the wine's generous weight, filled with "succulent strawberries and cherries," and a freshness instilled by "tangy tangerine." Decanter describes the tannins as "long chalky" and the finish as resonating with "rosemary and sage."
James Suckling awarded the wine an impressive 95 points, describing it as having "delightful aromas of juicy red cherries, strawberries, rose petals, and wild bush," along with "hints of juniper and ground herbs." He mentioned that the wine is medium-bodied with "firm tannins and crisp acidity," recommending to try it after 2027 for its optimal performance.
Jeb Dunnuck also gave a score of 94 points, praising its "warming bouquet of black raspberry, licorice candies, polished leather, and sappy forest herbs." Dunnuck found the wine to be "rounded and approachable," with "sweet tannins and balanced acidity," concluding that it is a "beautifully styled wine" that can be enjoyed from 2025 to 2040.
Robert Parker's Wine Advocate echoed similar sentiments with a 94-point rating. The review praised the wine's enhanced depth and volume compared to previous vintages, showcasing "sweet cherry and blackberry" integrated with "softly toasted spice and earth." The review also mentioned "floral hints of lilac and iris" and commended its "velvety tannins" and "nicely concentrated mid-weight palate."
Vinous described the wine as having a "spice box display" of "crushed ashen stones, cloves, dried black cherries, rosemary, and balsam herbs," earning it a 94-point rating. The wine was noted for its "surprisingly fresh and energetic" character, with "silken textures" and a "spicy and long" finish.
Wine Spectator gave the wine a stellar 95 points, remarking on its "ripe cherry, plum, and raspberry fruit," with "floral, mineral, juniper, and wild herb accents." The review highlighted its "excellent balance" and long-lasting aftertaste, recommending it for best enjoyment from 2027 through 2045.
Finally, Kerin O'Keefe awarded the highest score of 96 points, calling it a "gorgeous 2019 Brunello" with aromas of "ripe dark-skinned berry, blue flower, camphor, and pipe tobacco." O'Keefe noted its "captivating, youthful tension" and "elegantly structured" palate, suggesting it will drink best between 2028 and 2039.
Overall, the 2019 Argiano Brunello di Montalcino stands out for its excellent balance, depth, and complexity, making it a highly recommended choice for wine enthusiasts.