The 2019 Castello di Fonterutoli Siepi IGT is a proprietary blend of Sangiovese and Merlot produced by Mazzei Castello di Fonterutoli in Tuscany, Italy. This vintage is particularly notable for its high praise from several respected wine reviewers, indicating its exceptional quality and potential for aging.
Decanter awarded the wine a score of 96, highlighting its "power and seduction" on the nose with intense aromas of black cherries and blueberries. The palate is described as "juicy and instantly mouthwatering," featuring succulent red berries and a touch of herbal spice on the finish. The publication praised its smooth, silky texture and vibrant energy, noting that it is "drinking well now but will also age" (Decanter, 7/20/2021).
Vinous was even more enthusiastic, giving it a near-perfect score of 99. Reviewer Antonio Galloni emphasized the wine's "greater finesse and nuance," with flavors of crème de cassis, lavender, spice, licorice, and plum melding together effortlessly. Galloni described the 2019 Siepi as "exceptionally beautiful and riveting," calling it "a total knock-out" for its richness and concentration without heaviness (Vinous, 9/21/2021).
James Suckling also provided an excellent review, scoring the wine at 98. He described it as "really racy and fine" with characteristics of currant, black cherry, and dark chocolate. Suckling noted the wine's "very long, intense tannins" and "super structure," recommending it be tried after 2024 for optimal drinking (James Suckling, 9/6/2021).
Jane Anson gave the wine a score of 97, calling it a "brilliant vintage" with notes of raspberry, redcurrant, sage, tobacco leaf, and savory cherry pit. Anson praised its balance of delicacy and power, suggesting it would be highly enjoyable around a communal table (janeanson.com, 7/22/2021).
Wine Spectator also scored the wine at 96, commending its "perfumed and elegant" profile with vibrant cherry, black currant, and blackberry flavors. The wine features mineral, tobacco, wild herb, and spice accents, and is described as harmonious with "excellent finesse and a long aftertaste" (Wine Spectator, 2/9/2022).
Finally, Robert Parker's Wine Advocate also rated the wine at 96, noting its "special achievement" and ideal growing conditions. Reviewer Monica Larner mentioned the wine's balance of dark fruit, mineral, and spice aromas, supported by soft tannins and a generous texture (Robert Parker's Wine Advocate, 4/21/2022).
Overall, the 2019 Castello di Fonterutoli Siepi IGT is a standout vintage that has garnered high praise for its finesse, complexity, and aging potential.