The 2020 Le Macchiole Scrio is a Syrah from Tuscany, specifically the Bolgheri sub-region. This red wine has garnered significant attention from professional reviewers, achieving high scores across the board.
The Wine Independent awarded it a score of 96, describing it as "vibrant and fruity, full of blackberry, raspberry, cream, and sweet spice aromas." The review notes that while it is still young and simpler compared to the 2019 vintage, it shows "lots of concentration and potential" and is "joyful and beautifully made."
Vinous also gave it a 96, observing that the wine is "pretty closed" at this stage but suggests this is a positive indicator for long-term aging. Reviewer AG highlighted notes of "white pepper, smoke, dried flowers, mint, and chalk" that add brightness to its core of "sweet red and blood orange fruit." This vintage marks a shift in vineyard sourcing to a site in the hills of Bolgheri, and it was aged in a combination of 12hL cask, ceramic, and 10% French oak.
James Suckling rated it 94, appreciating its "plenty of flowers and fresh fruit such as blackberries and raspberries" along with "hints of cloves and nutmeg." He noted its "ultra-fine tannins and a chewy and crunchy finish," recommending it for drinking after 2026.
Wine Enthusiast's Danielle Callegari gave another 96, employing flowery language to describe it as having a nose "like a well-tailored suit" with "fireworks of black pepper" and a "spicy, bitter chocolate crescendo." She praised the wine's "debonair tannins" and "inconspicuous but unforgettable" acidity.
Wine Spectator also awarded it 94, noting its sleek and elegant nature with aromas and flavors of "violet, blueberry, boysenberry, earth, and spice." They praised its "fine-grained tannins" and "superb finesse and balance."
Robert Parker's Wine Advocate provided the highest score of 97, highlighting its "impeccable elegance" and "very long and linear style." The review praised the team at Le Macchiole for bringing out varietal nuances like "dark fruit, baking chocolate, spice, charred meat, white pepper, and pencil shaving."
Finally, Jeb Dunnuck's Audrey Frick echoed the high praise with another 97, describing it as "floral and inviting" with aromas of "fresh lavender, candied black raspberry, mocha, and sweet herbs." She noted its "buoyant and mouthwatering finish" and "mineral texture" that makes it "one stunner of a wine."
In summary, the 2020 Le Macchiole Scrio is a highly regarded Syrah with excellent aging potential, praised for its vibrant fruit profile, complex aromas, and elegant structure.