Château Trotanoy 2020 is a Pomerol from the Moueix family, drawn from the western Pomerol plateau’s black clay with iron deposits, close to neighbors such as Pétrus and Lafleur. In 2020, it lands squarely in Trotanoy’s house style: dense, mineral-tinged Merlot fruit with overt structure and a long aging curve. Alcohol is reported at 14.7% (one source places it nearer 15%), and the cépage is described as Merlot-dominant—though reviewers disagree on the exact proportions, with at least one calling it “100% Merlot” (The Wine Independent).
The wine’s critical reception is outstanding, with multiple top-tier scores. James Suckling awarded 100 points, highlighting “perfume and finesse… fresh flowers, blackberries, crushed stones and cement,” and calling it “full and very long with tight and muscular tannins,” advising, “Try after 2030.” Decanter also gave 100, calling it “a sure fire hit in 2020,” with “perfumed black cherries, roses and dark chocolate,” and praising “crushed velvet-textured tannins” and a balance where “nothing feels overworked.” Jeb Dunnuck joined with another 100, describing a “classic, concentrated, structured, regal style,” and said it will “need a decade of bottle age… pure Pomerol brilliance.”
Other excellent reviews reinforce the message: Jane Anson scored 100 and noted a September 15–18 harvest and 42 hl/ha yield, describing it as “muscular, powerful, precise” and “oh-so-clearly long ageing,” with tannins “closed right now.” The Wine Independent likewise scored 100 and emphasized how tightly wound it is today: “shut down tight,” “almost impenetrable,” and “finishing long and profound,” recommending “10-15 years at least.”
Vinous (Neal Martin) scored 98 for its “delineation and precision,” with black cherry, truffle, “crushed stone and loam,” concluding there is “a long, long road ahead.” Wine Spectator’s 96 finds it “alluring and lush” yet focused, best “from 2026 through 2040.” Overall, this is a benchmark, cellar-driven Trotanoy.