The 2021 Cayuse Syrah No Girls La Placienda Vineyard is a compelling Syrah from the Walla Walla appellation in Washington's Columbia Valley. This wine showcases the distinctive character of its biodynamically-grown grapes, with reviewers praising its complex aromatics and vibrant palate.
James Suckling awarded this Syrah a score of 96, highlighting its "fantastic aromatics of red plums, Sichuan peppercorns, herbs, Chinese five spice and small raspberries." He noted its meaty yet fruity profile, emphasizing the "fine and nervy tannins" that run through the medium-bodied wine.
Jeb Dunnuck was equally impressed, giving it an outstanding score of 97. He described the wine as a "beautiful example of Walla Walla Syrah," with "smoky red and black fruits, spring flowers, rose, ground pepper, and some gamey, meaty nuances." Dunnuck praised its supple, seamless mouthfeel and predicted it would evolve gracefully over the next 10–15 years.
Vinous also commended this Syrah, rating it 94 points. Eric Guido noted its "pretty blend of violets, lavender, crushed rocks, and dusty blackberries" on the nose, paired with a savory core of red and black fruits. He emphasized the structured tannins and advised that patience would be rewarded as the wine continues to develop.
Robert Parker's Wine Advocate offered a slightly more reserved score of 92+, mentioning its "deep magenta core" and aromas of "dusty black cherry skin, spiced plum, and turned earth." The review suggested the wine is still firm and tight, needing more time to integrate fully.
Wine Enthusiast's Michael Alberty, however, gave it another top score of 97, describing the wine as "packed with aromas and flavors of dark cherry, orange peel, black tea," and intriguing touches of jicama, turmeric, and ginger, making it a thrilling experience.
Overall, this Syrah is lauded for its complexity and potential for aging, with multiple reviewers recommending it as a standout example of the variety.