The 2021 Muller-Catoir Burgergarten Erste Lage Riesling is a distinguished white wine from the Pfalz region of Germany, specifically Haardt an der Weinstrabe in the Burgergarten appellation. Produced by the esteemed Muller-Catoir winery, this Riesling is notable for its exceptional quality and craftsmanship.

James Suckling of jamessuckling.com awarded this wine an impressive score of 95 points. He describes it as "a stunning single-vineyard dry Riesling with apricot and mango aromas plus a wonderful harmony of ripeness and freshness on the generous and concentrated palate." He emphasizes the "fine tannins and mineral acidity at the finish" which support the wine beautifully, noting an abundance of "apricot character and citrusy freshness at the very long finish." Suckling highlights that the grapes are organically grown, adding an additional layer of respectability to its production.

Robert Parker's Wine Advocate, represented by Stephan Reinhardt, gave the wine a score of 93+, noting its origins from vines over 45 years old planted in yellow-colored sandstone soils. Reinhardt describes the wine as having "dense and fully ripe fruit with clear, refreshingly mineral, lemon and herbal notes." He also points out the presence of iodine notes, which contribute to its distinct stony nose. On the palate, Reinhardt finds the wine "full-bodied, lush, and crystalline," with "fine mineral grip and acidity." The finish is described as "long, intense, and powerful yet also fine and elegant," with an added touch of "stimulating salinity and finesse." He mentions that the wine is reminiscent of classic Rieslings from the 1990s, though unique in its own right.

With an alcohol content of 13%, this dry Riesling is sealed with a natural cork stopper. The combined reviews from these respected critics underscore the wine’s balance, elegance, and complexity, making it a noteworthy choice for both immediate enjoyment and potential aging.