The 2022 Lucia by Pisoni Garys Vineyard Pinot Noir, hailing from the Santa Lucia Highlands in Monterey, California, is a Pinot Noir that has garnered high praise from top reviewers for its complexity, depth, and excellent aging potential.

Jeb Dunnuck rated this wine a 95, describing it as "one of the darker, more masculine style Pinots in the lineup." He noted the presence of "ripe black cherries, iron, roasted herbs, leather, and violet notes" in the aroma, and highlighted its "medium to full-bodied" palate with "concentrated, focused mouthfeel, beautiful tannins, and a great finish." Dunnuck recommended a decant if consuming soon and projected an "easy decade of prime drinking going forward," emphasizing its impressive nature.

Vinous also provided a strong review, awarding it a score of 94. According to Vinous, the wine is "generous, rich and ample," showcasing "pliant dark fruit, chalky tannins and a fresh array of juicy berry fruit." The review pointed out that the 25-year-old vines are yielding a Pinot of real complexity, with the 50% new oak contributing to its richness and roundness. However, Vinous suggested that the oak influence is "a little loud" and would benefit from "a year or two in bottle" to fully integrate.

Perhaps the most glowing review came from Wine Enthusiast, which bestowed a 97 rating on the wine. Matt Kettmann praised the "lovely layers of black cherry compote and star anise," which are complemented by "rich spice and dark fruit" on the nose. He further described the wine as having "ample acidity and texture" that frame the "dense but bright red fruit and baking spice flavors," leading into a "clean, fresh and intense finish."

Overall, the 2022 Lucia by Pisoni Garys Vineyard Pinot Noir is a standout wine from one of the region's most iconic vineyards, with reviewers noting its rich fruit profile, complex structure, and excellent aging potential.