The 2023 Arterberry Maresh Pinot Noir from the Maresh Vineyard in Oregon's Willamette Valley is a wine that has garnered significant attention from critics for its complexity and promise. This Pinot Noir, a product of Arterberry, is characterized by its deep red color and intricate flavor profile.

James Suckling awarded this wine an impressive score of 98, noting its "tense and savory" nature, layered with spicy herbs and black pepper. He highlights the wine's "pure, elegant fruit wrapped in blood-orange zest" and describes its structure as "tightly wound, with firm, deeply rooted tannins and almost endless length." Suckling suggests that the wine's complexity, with hints of bitter oranges, seashells, iron, and crushed bricks, makes it ideal for aging and recommends cellaring it until 2029 for optimal enjoyment.

Vinous' Eric Guido also praises this 2023 vintage, giving it a score of 96. He describes the wine as "impossible to ignore," with enticing notes of "crushed cherries and minty herbs," complemented by a hint of clove and stone dust. Guido emphasizes the wine's elegance, noting the "velvety textures" and "cool-toned acidity" that allow the red and blue fruits to swirl across the palate. The wine's structure is enhanced by a "web of fine-grained tannins" that provide both poise and length, leaving behind inner rose tones and a "pleasantly bitter twang."

Overall, the 2023 Arterberry Maresh Pinot Noir is a highly regarded wine, praised for its complexity and potential for aging. Both reviewers highlight its intricate flavor profile and structure, making it a standout choice for those looking to invest in a wine that promises to mature beautifully over time.