The 2019 Haut Bages Liberal from Bordeaux's Pauillac region is an impressive red wine, crafted with an 80% Cabernet Sauvignon and 20% Merlot blend. It showcases the vineyard's commitment to biodynamic farming, with grapes grown organically on clay-limestone and gravel soils. This vintage is noted for its complexity and refinement, gaining excellent reviews from several wine critics.

James Suckling awarded this wine a score of 96, praising its "complex nose of blackberries, currants, oyster shells, iodine, gravel, cloves, dried leaves and bark." He highlighted its "firm, very fine tannins" and described it as "layered and serious" with an "extremely long finish." He recommends it for aging, suggesting to try it after 2026.

Wine Enthusiast's Roger Voss rated it 95, commenting on its "succulent black fruits" and "firm, spicy structure." He noted the wine's density and aging potential, suggesting it to be enjoyed from 2026 onwards. He also emphasized the impressive performance of this wine from its southern Pauillac vineyard.

Vinous, with a score of 94, described the wine as "gorgeous" with "hints of crushed red berry fruit, mint, spice, rose petal and orange peel." Antonio Galloni appreciated its "overall energy and aromatic presence," recommending a few years of aging for it to fully develop.

Decanter, with a 93 score, appreciated the wine's "dark black bramble fruits" and "blackcurrant juiciness." They found it to have "power but clarity" with a "menthol/liquorice finish common to Pauillac."

Robert Parker's Wine Advocate also awarded a 94, noting its "velvety and seamless palate" and "powdery structuring tannins" well-integrated with lively fruit. William Kelley called it a "terrific effort" from a lesser-known estate.

Overall, the 2019 Haut Bages Liberal is a wine of depth and elegance, promising enjoyment for years to come.