The 2019 Haut Batailley is a Bordeaux blend from the Pauillac region in France, known for its quintessentially Pauillac characteristics. This wine has been well-received by critics, with several praising its balance, structure, and potential for aging.
James Suckling awarded it a score of 95, highlighting its "linear and tight" profile with "blue fruit and fine tannins" alongside hints of graphite and lead pencil. He describes it as "delicate, yet structured," recommending to try it after 2026. Jeb Dunnuck echoes this sentiment, also scoring it 95, noting its "gorgeous array of red and black currants, black raspberries, tobacco, and flowers," praising its balance and concentration and calling it a "gem of a Pauillac."
Jeff Leve and Vinous both rated it 94. Leve describes it as "full-bodied, concentrated, powerful, tannic and backward," suggesting that it will reveal more character with age, while Vinous highlights its "very attractive, wonderfully delineated bouquet" with a "medium-bodied" palate and "fine tannins."
Decanter and Wine Enthusiast also commend the wine with scores of 93 and 94, respectively. Decanter appreciates its "expressive nose and excellent clarity on the palate" with "impactful tannins," while Wine Enthusiast notes the estate's improvement under the Cazes family, highlighting its "power and structure" and "ripe jammy fruits."
Robert Parker's Wine Advocate and Wine Spectator add to the positive reception, both giving scores of 93. The former mentions "aromas of minty berries, loamy soil, violets, cedar, and spices," while the latter describes it as having "red and black currant, plum and blackberry preserve flavors" with a "lovely savory/cedar echo."
Overall, the 2019 Haut Batailley is praised for its classic Pauillac traits, complexity, and potential for aging, making it a standout vintage under the Cazes family management.