The 2019 Podere Poggio Scalette Il Carbonaione is a remarkable red wine that epitomizes the excellence of Sangiovese. Hailing from the renowned region of Tuscany in Italy, this wine showcases the mastery of the winemaking craft by Podere Poggio Scalette. With its deep red color and enticing aromas, it is a true delight for the senses.
Upon pouring, the 2019 Il Carbonaione reveals a captivating bouquet of sour cherries and orange peel. These vibrant and expressive aromas entice the nose and prepare the palate for an extraordinary tasting experience. On the palate, this wine exhibits a full body with layered tannins that are both creamy and juicy, providing a velvety texture that is truly indulgent.
The finish of the 2019 Il Carbonaione is intense and enduring, leaving a lasting impression on the palate. Its excellent structure ensures that the wine will continue to evolve and improve with time, making it an ideal candidate for cellaring. James Suckling, a renowned wine critic, recommends drinking this wine after 2024 to allow it to soften and further develop its complexity.
Antonio Galloni from Vinous also praises the wine, giving it a score of 93+ points. While noting the presence of new oak scents, Galloni acknowledges the wine's potential for aging, as Il Carbonaione has a brilliant track record in this regard. He identifies ripe red and blush fruit, sweet spice, mocha, and rose petal flavors that linger harmoniously on the palate.
The Wine Spectator, another esteemed publication, rates the 2019 Il Carbonaione with 92 points. They describe it as intense and supple, with a smoky aroma that is complemented by blackberry, plum, earth, and charred wood flavors. The wine's lively acidity and firm tannins provide a balanced structure, and it is recommended to be enjoyed from 2024 through 2035.
Overall, the 2019 Podere Poggio Scalette Il Carbonaione is a wine of exceptional quality and finesse. Its impressive reviews from esteemed critics attest to its excellence, and it is a testament to the artistry of Sangiovese winemaking in Tuscany. Whether savored now or aged for future enjoyment, this wine is certain to captivate the most discerning wine enthusiasts.